Runaway ads and Servant contracts: two inconsistent measures of the medium of exchange.

The connection between Grubb (2003, 2004a) and Grubb’s paper (2004b) on the colonial era raises yet another objection. In Grubb (2004b), the medium of exchange is inferred from runaway ads in the Pennsylvania Gazette, and Grubb vigorously defends this as a valid technique. In Grubb (2004a), he uses indentured servant transactions recorded in Redemptioner’s A for the same purpose, and vigorously defends the validity of the conclusions he draws based on that source. Our position is that you can’t infer the medium of exchange from the unit of account whether you are counting runaway ads or servant contracts. However, since servants continued to run away after the Revolution as well as before, and since Grubb has so ardently defended both measures, it is interesting to examine the unit of account in runaway servant advertisements in the Pennsylvania Gazette, 1784-1800. Footnote


Runaway Servant Advertisements in the Pennsylvania Gazette, 1784-1800
Year Number offering reward in pounds Number offering reward in dollars Percent in Dollars
1784 7 22 75.86
1785 11 33 75.00
1786 2 15 88.24
1787 3 13 81.25
1788 3 10 76.92
1789 4 8 66.67
1790 2 15 88.24
1791 3 10 76.92
1792 8 16 66.67
1793 3 18 85.71
1794 4 28 87.50
1795 1 16 94.12
1796 0 17 100.00
1797 2 8 80.00
1798 0 7 100.00
1799 0 6 100.00
1800 0 0 ----

Until the second half of 1796, virtually all the current transactions recorded in Redemptioners’ Book A are in pounds, not dollars. The runaway ads tell a completely different story, illustrating once again how treacherous it is to attempt to draw conclusions about the medium of exchange from such evidence.