|
The Legal Tender Status of Bills of Credit Was colonial currency a legal tender in private debts? How about confederation era currency? No one, so far as we know, disputes that Federalists and hard-money advocates frequently objected to the injustices created by inflation when creditors were forced to accept legal tender paper money at its face value in payment of private debts. At issue is whether this concern was genuine, or whether this was simply an argument advanced by rent-seeking bankers to unfairly demonize paper money. We lean to the first explanation, and Grubb the second. If legal tender provisions were the exception, rather than the rule, as Grubb would have us believe, Federalists’ concerns on this score would clearly be overblown. Grubb’s position (p. 1779) is that “Typically, colonial bills of credit ... were not a legal tender for all debts. However, because they were always, explicitly by law, accepted in payment for the issuing government’s taxes at an announced rate relative to pound sterling, they were de facto legal tender for public debts. This, in turn, provided the anchor that allowed the bills to circulate as cash within that colony.” Currency practices varied from colony to colony and over time, so all generalizations are subject to qualification. However, McCusker’s (1978, p.119) summary judgment that “bills of credit eventually had in law the status of legal tender” is considerably more defensible than Grubb’s assertion to the contrary. Before reviewing the historical evidence, however, it is worth noting that the precise meaning of “a legal tender in private contracts” is ambiguous, and one can distinguish several variants. The first and most stringent variety of legal tender laws not only forces creditors to accept paper money in payment of debts, but outlaws what we would today call gold clauses. The second variety of legal tender laws forces creditors to accept paper money in payment of debts when the contract contains no specific provision (e.g. a gold clause) calling for some other form of payment. Provisions similar to gold clauses, detailing that payment was to be made in specie or in sterling, were sometimes found in colonial era contracts, and contracts containing such provisions were then known as “specialties.” Of course, if a legal tender law allows exceptions in the form of gold clauses or specialties, creditors can – at a cost – negate the legal tender provisions by writing specific payment terms into contracts. Since 1977, gold clauses have been legal and enforceable in the United States, but we still think it important that Federal Reserve notes are legal tender because so few contracts actually contain such clauses. This was true in colonial times, too, for Thomas Hutchinson remarked that simple contracts outnumbered specialties by ten to one (Hutchinson, 1936, vol. II, p. 335). A third variant on legal tender is a law that says the tendering of paper money is not sufficient to extinguish a debt, but prohibits the courts from issuing any judgment against a debtor who tenders it. Under this heading I would also include the formula used by New York during the confederation: New York’s bills were only a legal tender if the creditor brought suit (Nevins, 1924, p.528). Both schemes offer the creditor the option of accepting payment in bills of credit now, or keeping the debt alive in hope of more substantial payment later. When adopted as a temporary expedient, such a law is akin to a stay law. However, when such a law stays on the books for decades, it becomes equivalent in its effect to a legal tender act. Laws of this kind might be further subdivided depending on how they treated gold clauses or specialties. Massachusetts issued her first bills in 1690, but did not begin paper money emissions in earnest until 1702. Legal tender status of the third variety (Massachusetts permitted specialties) was first attached to the bills in 1712, and periodically renewed until the bills were finally abolished in 1750 (Massachusetts, 1869-1922, vol. I, pp. 700-01; vol. II, pp. 24, 267, 589-90). The only caveat is that during the 1740s Governor Shirley persuaded the legislature to mandate an allowance for depreciation – a sort of colony-wide indexing. The colony never summoned the political will to insist on more than an inadequate token allowance for depreciation, however, so these provisions were of slight consequence (Hutchinson, 1936, vol. 2, pp. 306-7). In Pennsylvania, the bills were a legal tender from the beginning. There was nothing half-hearted about Pennsylvania’s legal tender provision, which were of the first variety:
[The bills] ... shall be received and paid for the same value, and equal to the current coin passing in this province, for goods or any other thing bought and sold by all persons whatsoever residing in and passing through this province, according to their rates; and the tender of the said bills for payment or discharging of any debt or debts, bargain, sale of lands, or other things, bonds, mortgages, specialties and contracts whatsoever, already made, or hereafter to be made, either for sterling money, silver money of America, dollars, or any other species of gold or silver, or any quantity of plate or gold, shall be as effectual in the law, to all intents and purposes, as if the current silver coin of this province had been offered and tendered for the discharge of the same or any part thereof (Pennsylvania, 1896-, vol. 3, p. 329).
New York’s first emission, in 1709, was not legal tender in private contracts but that changed beginning with the colony’s second emission in 1714. This act included new provisions to enforce the currency of the bills. Any creditor “refusing to accept the said Bills of Credit . . . shall lose the said Debt,” and [they and their heirs] “shall for ever be barred from bringing . . . Action for the Recovery of the said Debt.” In addition, anyone who, in the sale of goods should “deny or refuse to sell, or ask a greater Value for the same, unless Payment be made in current Silver Money, Gold Plate Dollars, or other Species whatsoever, and not in the said Bills of Credit . . . shall . . . [for goods] under the Value of Five Pounds, Forfeit the Sum of Forty Shillings for each Offence.” The fine escalated for larger transactions, to £5, then £10, and finally, on transactions above £100, the fine was £50 (New York, 1894, vol. 1, pp. 815-26). Colden characterized these provisions as a “despotic” interference with private contracts, that had originated with “the Popular part of our Constitution and [were] carried merely by their weight (Colden, 1740).”
The situation in South Carolina was more complicated. South Carolina issued two distinct kinds of paper money: bills of credit and “public orders.” The first bills of credit issued, in 1703, were not a legal tender, but beginning in 1707 newly issued bills of credit were a legal tender in payment of private debts for sums up to forty shillings (Brock, 1975, p. 117). In 1731 all the bills of credit then outstanding, £106,500, were ordered reprinted and made a legal tender in all payments. Since no redemption provisions whatsoever were attached to these bills, those that survived wear and tear (the bills were reprinted in 1748) continued to circulate until the Revolution (Brock, 1975, p. 123). South Carolina first issued public orders in 1731. Ostensibly, public orders were not a legal tender in private contracts, but “custom caused them to circulate much as the legal tender bills did” (Brock, 1975, p. 124). New Jersey’s bills of credit were a legal tender of the first variety in private transactions from their first emission in 1709 (New Jersey, 1929, p. 69; Brock, 1975, pp. 87-8). Some of the bills New Jersey issued during the French and Indian war were designed to remain in circulation until 1783. As a consequence of the long terms on which these bills were issued, New Jersey possessed a legal tender paper currency right up to the Revolution (Brock, pp. 402, 409).
Virginia’s bills of credit, first issued during the French and Indian War, were also made a full legal tender from the beginning (Ernst, 1973, p. 50). This, of course, is unsurprising, as the Currency Act of 1764 was passed in response to Virginia’s actions.
Parliament passed the Currency Acts of 1751 and 1764 with the intention of limiting legal tender paper monies in the colonies. Here is what Grubb says about these acts:
The British Crown’s response to the Massachusetts crisis [the inflation during the late 1740s] was the Currency Act of 1751 which allowed colonies to issue paper money as long as it met two conditions: (1) that it not be legal tender, and (2) that ample provisions (taxes) be put in place to redeem each issue “within as short and reasonable a time as may be, not exceeding five years at the farthest” (Danby Pickeering, 1765, vol. 20, pp. 306-09). This Act only applied to New England, but was later extended to all colonies by the Currency Act of 1764. Some colonies, such as Maryland, Pennsylvania, and New York, had instituted such policies on their own accord well before 1760 (Grubb, 2003, p. 1779).
To dispose of a minor error first, the Currency Act of 1751 was not passed in response to the actions of Massachusetts; the situation in Massachusetts had already been resolved when that colony adopted a comprehensive currency reform in 1749 and implemented it in 1750. It was passed to constrain Rhode Island, whose plan to emit a substantial sum of paper money led a group of Rhode Island merchants to petition for Parliamentary intervention (Brock, 1975, pp. 231-32).
Many historians incorrectly assume that when the Currency Acts took effect that they immediately abolished legal tender paper money. This is incorrect: The acts prohibited the colonies from issuing additional legal tender paper money, or renewing that in circulation, but did nothing to strip the legal tender status from existing bills circulating within their assigned periods. So in South Carolina, whose legal tender paper money bore no expiration date whatsoever, or in New Jersey, where the legal tender emissions of the French and Indian War were designed to circulate until 1783, full legal tender paper money still circulated on the eve of the Revolution, entirely in accord with the spirit and letter of British law.
Grubb’s contention that Maryland, Pennsylvania, and New York had instituted policies consonant with the two principles embodied in the Currency Act of 1751 “well before 1760” is mistaken. Maryland’s solitary issue before 1764 was emitted in 1733 and was not designed to be fully retired until 1764, which was not the “short and reasonable” time envisioned in the Currency Act. Moreover, while McCusker (1978, p. 190) asserted that “Maryland bills of credit . . . were not constituted legal tender for private debt,” this is only true of post-1764 emissions. The1733 issuing act declared “the said Bills of Credit shall pass in Payment, Satisfaction, and Discharge of all Contracts to be made from and after the Publication of this Act, within this Province, for Current Money” (Maryland, 1883-1972, vol. 39, p. 95). Maryland’s bills were a legal tender of the second kind, albeit one that exempted pre-existing contracts. All New York’s emissions before the Currency Act of 1764 were a full legal tender, despite the objections of imperial authorities, and many of the bills so issued were designed to circulate beyond the five year limit (Brock, 1975, pp. 342-3). The full legal tender provisions of New York’s currency did not lapse until 1768. Pennsylvania, likewise, made all her French and Indian War issues a full legal tender and stretched the currency of many of them beyond the five year limit. Pennsylvania even emitted currency in 1764 as a full legal tender, designed to be current until 1772, slipping one last emission in before the constraints of the Currency Act of 1764 went into effect (Pennsylvania, 1896-, vol. 6, p. 363).
Not only were the provisions of the Currency Acts less restrictive than many historians realize, but the acts were evaded in the colonies. When it became clear that Parliament was unlikely to repeal the Currency Act of 1764, Charles Garth, South Carolina’s agent in London, recommended that South Carolina issue currency that was not a legal tender, while informally directing the colony treasurer to keep some of the legal tender issue at hand to exchange for the new emission, in case a creditor balked at accepting it (Garth, 1928, pp. 300-1). Pennsylvania seems to have used a similar subterfuge, since its acts emitting non-legal tender currency contain provisions making it freely exchangeable at the Pennsylvania treasury for “lawful currency” – the remnants of the earlier legal tender issues (Ernst, 1973, pp. 128, 212-13, 305).
Passage of a Currency Act hardly guaranteed its enforcement. Colonial Rhode Island, too small to attract much attention, and with a liberal charter that did not even require colony laws to be routinely forwarded to London for review, flaunted it. One of the provisions of the Currency Act of 1751 held that any act whereby such “Bills of Credit, as are already subsisting and passing in Payment, within any of the said Colonies or Plantations, ... shall be depreciated in Value” was ipso facto “null and void.” In March 1751, Rhode Island had passed a law declaring that henceforth each 54 s. old tenor of her paper money should be worth one ounce of silver, and instructing Rhode Island’s courts that, in the event of any depreciation, the silver and not the paper value should be the standard of payment (Rhode Island, 1856-65, vol. 5, pp. 318-19). Nonetheless, Rhode Island repealed this provision in 1754, and Rhode Island’s courts never once enforced it, although Rhode Island’s bills of credit continued to depreciate (Rhode Island, 1856-65, vol. 5, p. 392; Connecticut, 1677-1789, vol. IV, pp. 402, 404, 407). In 1763, Rhode Island passed “An Act Declaring What Is, and Shall Be, Lawful Money of this Colony, etc.” which officially declared that 140 s. old tenor of her paper money should be worth one silver dollar (equivalent to 160 s. old tenor per ounce) and declared certain other bills a legal tender in private bargains, excepting only contracts that contained an explicit clause calling for payment in specie (Rhode Island, 1856-65, vol. 6, pp. 358-62). While creditors in colonial Rhode Island fully understood the colony’s actions violated Parliamentary edict, there was little they could do about it (Bannister, 1761-1771, letters to William Johnson July 27, 1761; February 24, 1763). Nor were these the only ways to create legal tender and evade the spirit of the Currency Acts. Ultimately, what was legal tender in a colony depended on the ruling of local courts – appeal to England being absolutely prohibited in small judgments, and prohibitively costly in most other cases. For example, it was a Virginia court that seems to have first decreed that Maryland money should be rated at the same value as Pennsylvania money (McCusker, 1978, p. 192). In Connecticut, where not even the old tenor bills issued by the Connecticut government were declared a legal tender in the issuing acts, the local courts ruled in the early 1750s that even Rhode Island and New Hampshire bills had to be accepted, at face value, in payment of old tenor debts when contracts were mute to the form of payment, effectively making them a legal tender within Connecticut. The debate over this ruling makes clear that no one doubted that Connecticut bills had to be accepted in that fashion, although some objected heatedly to extending that to the (less valuable) bills of neighboring colonies (Sherman, 1752; Gale, 1755). In the cases of Dering vs. Packer, and Trecothick vs. Wentworth, the New Hampshire courts in the late 1750s ruled that ancient debts incurred by New Hampshire residents to a Boston merchant and a London merchant, respectively, could be extinguished by the payment at face value of heavily depreciated New Hampshire bills of credit. These cases were exceptional in that they were appealed to the Privy Council in England; small cases could not be so appealed, and few eligible for appeal would bear the cost of appeal (Great Britain. Privy Council, 1908-1912, vol. IV, pp. 393-4, 433-6; Smith, 1950, pp. 500-2). Grubb also implies that confederation-era emissions were seldom legal tender in private dealings. But legal tender emissions were common in the confederation era too. Seven states issued paper money after 1783: Pennsylvania, North Carolina, South Carolina, Rhode Island, New York, New Jersey, and Georgia. Of those, only the emissions of Pennsylvania and South Carolina were not a legal tender for private debts (Nevins, 1924; Kaminski, 1989; Morrill, 1969; Hall, 1991).
This extensive discussion is designed to convince the reader that, contrary to the impression left by Grubb, early American paper monies were more commonly a legal tender in private debts than not. Complaints about the injustices inherent in legal tender provisions, accordingly, should not be dismissed out of hand. |